High court overturns inspector's rejection of 644 homes plan for south Lancaster
A high court judge has overturned a planning inspector’s decision to reject a major housing scheme near Galgate.
Siding with Gladman Developments, the judge ruled that it was wrong to dismiss the Bailrigg application just because of a lack of sequential test for flood risk.
The high court verdict saw the conclusion of a two-year process which began with Lancaster City Council’s initial refusal of the project in December 2023.
At that time, a risk of flooding was listed among the reasons for refusal, despite only a small part of its western boundary being within flood zones.


The Environment Agency had not objected to the scheme, and Gladman claimed its proposed surface water drainage strategy would reduce the risk of flooding on the site.
In November 2024, the planning inspectorate agreed with the city council.
However, the inspector dismissed three grounds for refusal from the city council: qualms over urban design, impact on nearby heritage, and effects on nearby protected sites.
Instead, only one reason did stand – the lack of a sequential test due to flood risk.


Property news site Place North West has now reported that Melissa Murphy, King’s counsel at Landmark Chambers representing Gladman, successfully argued that the inspector erred in law by seeing the lack of a sequential test as reason for an automatic dismissal.
The High Court justice agreed with Murphy, noting that the project, by the inspector’s own admission, would lower the likelihood of flood risk.
The judge said that the inspector had not weighed the planning balance accurately by giving the lack of a sequential test the power to stop an application without consideration of other factors.
In addition, planning policy has moved on since the planning appeal was held, and new guidance dictates that sequential tests are not necessary in the case of projects where a flood risk assessment can demonstrate that surface water flooding will decrease flood risk.


A Lancaster City Council spokesman said: “Lancaster City Council notes the judgment of the high court to quash the appeal decision that had been made by a planning inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government.
“The council is currently reviewing the decision and its options. It cannot give any further comments at this time.”
Gladman have also been approached for comment.