Lancaster mum sparks online debate over school juice ban

A Lancaster mum has ignited a heated online debate after a child was reprimanded for bringing juice to school.

The controversy began when Emma, a Lancaster mum and founder of "The Non Perfect Parents Club" Facebook page, which has 28,000 followers, shared a post on October 7.

The post recounted an incident where a teacher confronted the child of one of the page's members for bringing juice instead of water to school.

In the post, Emma expressed her frustration, writing: "Imagine being 5, and you don’t like to drink water, so your mum fills your drink bottle with cordial every day for school."

Emma, Founder of The Non Perfect Parents Club.placeholder image
Emma, Founder of The Non Perfect Parents Club.

She went on to describe how the child was singled out in class: "Imagine being 5, and you’re sitting in class when your teacher asks everyone to raise their hand if they have juice (not water) in their drink bottle."

Emma added: "You’re afraid not to raise your hand, worried the teacher will sniff your bottle, as you've seen her do to other kids, discover you have juice, and you’ll get in trouble. So, you raise your hand. And you have to watch as your teacher pours your juice out and refills your bottle with water."

The post quickly sparked a debate, with many parents supporting Emma's stance. One user commented: "The majority of juice is now sugar-free anyway, so what's the issue? Tap water, especially in hard water areas, tastes absolutely rank - I won't drink it myself. Schools, even primary schools, have become absolutely ridiculous."

Another parent shared a similar experience: "This happened to my son on one of the hottest days of the year! The TA poured his drink away in front of everyone and made him refill it with water. He didn’t drink it because he has sensory issues and doesn’t like water (neither do I)."

Lancashire County Hall.placeholder image
Lancashire County Hall.

A third comment highlighted concerns about children's well-being: "They are all about promoting healthy eating and drinking, which I get, but maybe they should also consider healthy bladder and bodily functions."

Some parents defended the school’s actions, with one commenting: "Imagine being 5 and learning about discipline - you can’t always have what you want."

Another added: "This is so dramatic for no reason. My 4-year-old would prefer juice at school, but juice isn’t allowed. So, he can drink water or go thirsty - that’s life, I’m afraid."

Another remarked: "I think this is on parents really. Kids shouldn’t just be drinking squash, which is full of sugars or horrendous artificial sweeteners. Water is best for your kids anyway."

A spokesman for Lancashire County Council said: "According to the latest government guidance, water should be available for children at all times but sugary or sweetened drinks often have no nutritional value, contribute to weight gain, and can cause tooth decay.

Each school can set their own policy for what is allowed in children's drinks bottles, and set their own rules on implementing these. Each school can also decide if a pupil's circumstances are exceptional, and may make exceptions on a case by case basis."

In a follow-up post on October 8, Emma clarified her position: "As many of you know, I’m always supportive of teachers and always say that teachers are as much victims of the system as our children are."

"I understand school’s protocol and policies etc., but there are some that I just can’t and will never get on board with because they’re quite frankly ridiculous, and I really don’t feel they actually benefit our children."

She continued: "As someone who worked in early years and offered a child-centred approach, it has always baffled me why this provision doesn’t continue when a child reaches school."

As of October 8th, her original post had been shared over 6 thousand times, generating over 1 thousand comments.

News you can trust since 1837
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice